Daniel Sutter: Are our highways less safe?


Daniel Sutter

Highway fatalities have increased from under 33,000 in 2014 to 37,461 in 2016, before declining slightly in 2017. Many have speculated whether drivers distracted by smart phones have caused this increase. Before further restricting driving, we should examine the problem.

The recent increase in fatalities is unsettling because driving has become safer over time. Fifty years ago, over 50,000 Americans died annually on the highways; the worst year was 1972 with 54,589 deaths, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Vehicle miles driven have increased dramatically as the death toll has fallen. Indeed, fatalities per mile driven have fallen by 80 percent since 1966. If we still had 1966’s fatality rate with today’s 3.2 trillion miles driven, we would have had 176,000 highway deaths in 2017.

Has driving truly become more deadly
since 2014? The increase in fatalities might seem to answer this in the
affirmative, but real world data never lies exactly on a smooth curve. Could
the recent increases in fatalities just be random variation?

The two largest year-to-year percentage
increases in highway fatalities were in 2015 and 2016, a total 14 percent
increase. And yet multi-year fatality increases have occurred since 1966,
including four consecutive years in the late 1970s and five consecutive years
in the 1990s. The 1970’s fatalities increase was 15 percent. The recent
increase in fatalities is not entirely unprecedented.

Thankfully, a very small percentage of
accidents produce fatalities. If roads are more dangerous, we should also see
increases in injuries and accidents. NHTSA injury totals go back only to 1988
and are much less accurate than fatalities data. Still, reported injuries
increased 34 percent, or 800,000, between 2014 and 2016, including a 28 percent
increase in 2016. The largest previous one-year increase in injuries was only
6.5 percent. Reliable nationwide totals on accidents are not available.

Not all states have seen fatality
increases. In Alabama fatalities rose 26 percent between 2014 and 2016. Rhode
Island had a 63 percent increase in fatalities, and eight other states saw
increases of 30 percent or more. Yet fatalities declined in three states and
increased less than 5 percent in four more. Are cell phones more distracting in
some states than others?

Substantial differences in fatality rates
exist across states. Between 2014 and 2017, South Carolina’s rate was more than
two and a half times higher than Massachusetts’. Factors like rural vs. urban
driving, highway type, and speed limits explain much of this variation, but making
driving in all states as safe as in the safest states could save thousands of
lives annually.

The NHTSA also reports fatalities by
vehicle type, which have increased by 12 and 13 percent for cars and light
trucks. Motorcyclists and bicyclists (15 percent each) and pedestrians (22 percent)
saw larger increases, even though drivers of cars and trucks seem more likely
to be distracted by cell phones. The fatality increases for cyclists and
pedestrians suggest another cause, or may combine drivers’ distractions and
these individuals’ vulnerability.

Cell phone use and texting have been around
longer than we perhaps remember; Washington state banned texting and driving in
2007. According to NHTSA statistics, drivers’ cell phone use has fallen over
the past decade, and fatalities fell 20 percent nationally between 2007 and
2014. New phones provide more ways to distract drivers, but why did cell phones
start increasing fatalities only in 2015?

Many scholars from different disciplines
study highway safety, including yours truly. To date, published research has
not really addressed the recent jump in fatalities. World events drive academic
research, so research should soon start offering concrete insights.

Highway fatalities continue to impose a
heavy toll on the U.S. Even though the fatality rate has fallen 80 percent
since 1966, the modest increase in fatalities since 2014 should concern citizens
and experts. Fortunately fatalities fell 3 percent during the first half of
2018. Perhaps the increase from 2014 to 2016 was only a pause in the long-term
improvement in highway safety.

Daniel Sutter is the Charles G. Koch Professor of Economics with the Manuel H. Johnson Center for Political Economy at Troy University and host of Econversations on TrojanVision. The opinions expressed in this column are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Troy University.


Comments are closed.

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons
%d bloggers like this: